How to compare AI models on evidence, not gut feel

The best model depends on the task. A side-by-side test on your own prompts beats any leaderboard.

Why leaderboards are not enough

Public benchmarks measure general ability. Your work is specific: your contract language, your support tone, your data. Two models with similar scores can differ a lot on your tasks, and on cost.

A simple model arena method

  • Collect 10-20 real prompts per task, with the answer you expect
  • Run each prompt across several models at once
  • Score answers against the expected result, with a judge model and a human check
  • Compare quality against cost per answer
  • Decide which models each team may use, and re-test when new models appear

Model Arena in WorkenAI

WorkenAI's Model Arena runs one prompt across several models, shows answers side by side and has a judge model score them. Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, xAI, Mistral and others work through one interface.

What we will show you

  • A prompt set and scoring sheet for one of your tasks

Questions

How often should we re-test?

Whenever a notable model is released or your task changes. A saved prompt set makes it quick.

Is a judge model reliable?

It is a fast first pass. Keep a human review on a sample.

Pick models with evidence

Tell us how your teams use AI today, which data must stay inside and who approves the rollout. We reply with a scope and the open questions.

Related